Thursday, 21 July 2011

Short-Selling and why is it regarded as high-risk investment?

Short-selling is a type of trading where the intention is to make a profit on a financial instrument (e.g. equity, commodities or derivatives) when the value of the instrument decreases rather than increases.

The most common form of dealing is buying shares at a certain price and then holding onto it for a certain amount of time and then selling it once the price has increased sufficiently or when you wish to realise a profit at a time that's suitable to you.  This is called going 'Long'. This is the basis of the saying, 'Buy Low and Sell High'. Everyone understands this concept and is simple to follow.

Shorting or Short-selling is the total opposite of going Long, i.e. it involves selling (borrowed) shares initially and then buying them back at a set time in the future and the profit is the difference between the price sold and the price bought. To paraphrase the above saying, the principle of short-selling is, 'Sell High and Buy Low'. But, how does it work in practice?

I'll illustrate it with a fictitious example. Let's say I have a friend who owns an expensive Ferrari that he loves and cherishes which he bought brand new a couple of years ago, and it's still worth a lot of money, say £100,000. But what he doesn't know is that Ferrari is about to announce a new model to the one he owns in 2 weeks time. So, somehow, I managed to persuade him to lend me his car for 1 month (30 days), and for his troubles for letting me borrow the car I'm going to offer him £200/day.

As soon as the car is in my possession, I sell the car for the current market value of £100,000, meaning I've just made £100,000 for a borrowed car, which I continue to pay £100/day to my friend. As expected, after 2 weeks, the news of a new model was released and suddenly the price of the current model nose-dived and at the end of 30 days, the price has dropped to, let's say £80,000. So I then go to a Ferrari dealer and buy the exact model of the car my friend owned (same colour, same year of manufacture and same specifications) for £80,000 from the £100,000 I originally received from the sale of his car. I then drive the car back to my friend, hand the car back to him and and walk away and in the process I made nearly £20,000, i.e.

Received from selling the car: £100,000 

Total borrowing fee over 30 days: £6000
Price paid to buy back a similar car: £80,000.
So, the total expense was £86,000.

Profit made = £100,000 - £86,000 = £14,000.

That's £14,000 for trading a car I do not own!! This is how Short-selling works: sell high (initially) and buy (back) when it's low.

I know you're going to say, "Wait a minute! Your friend's going to know that what you've given him is not his car because it won't have the same registration number or the same mileage". True, and I did say that this is a fictitious example.

But consider this: instead of the Ferrari, what if I borrowed his 10,000 shares of Apple stocks and did the same? Would he notice that the 10,000 shares I returned to him were not the same 10,000 shares that he lent to me? Of course not. A share is a share: it has no shape, size, smell or colour.

So, in practice, to short-sell a trade, you'd borrow shares from a lender (usually a broker) and pay him daily interest on it, and with an agreement to return the shares at a set date in the future, usually in a few days (rather than months). You'd then sell the shares immediately and then buy the same number of shares back on the due date at the current prevailing price, and you hope that by then the price would have dropped.

This last bit about price dropping is the reason why short-selling is a high risk investment strategy. Going back to our silly example above, what if instead of Ferrari announcing a new model they could have decided that they will no longer make any new car of the same model, making the current model (the one you just sold) the last model of its range. If that happens, the price of that model would have shot up due to the sudden realisation in the car enthusiasts market that there will be no more car like this ever.

Unlike a Long trade, when the price drops you can hold on to the shares as long as you can (months or years) until the prices comes back up again, with a Short trade, you don't have that luxury of waiting until the market is more favourable to you. Short-selling is bound by the time limit you can borrow the shares, so you HAVE to buy back the shares when the borrowed duration is up at whatever the current price is. Hence, if the stock market doesn't go in your favour then you're bound to lose a lot of money.


No comments: